I suffered from guilt ridden exits from bookstores off late for I end up buying books more than what I can read, and there is a bigger set of them waiting to be read at home. I am buying them because i can and because i really want to read them. Eight, is the record i recently created in a recent such trip. The differnce between the books I have bought and the once i have read are ever increasing. Even if i include the many that i have partly read.
I have though, wondered how much of a book does one need to read to have actually read it. I mean Non-Fiction here, as that's what i read unless i need a break. Sometimes its enough to read a half of it and you would get your perspective. Now if you really are the kinds who thinks you need to get the full money's/pages'/perspective's worth, you would have a guilt left, still. I would fit in there, most of the time.
I am certainly buying as much as i can afford, and have only felt convinced while doing so. That conviction!yes, that's how i end up buying at the first place! That feeling!, It is very similar to the strength of a brilliant excuse you mind gives you, to call office and make, when you are too sleepy to get up and leave for work in an hour. And the guilt that follows, if you actually happen to bunk that day.
I have sometimes forgotten about some books i bought. A casual look at the book-rack gives me a realisation of combined pride and guilt.
I have seen better reading days, cheaper too. Any book lover who has spent time long enough in Mumbai has not stopped thanking, and now missing, the days when a short walk (Flora Fountain to Churchgate station) , 150 Rupees and healthy negotiation skills would see you heading home with two or three fine titles. You would read them and return a month later to buy more. I earned much much lesser and yet i learned as much or more (and there was no google in my life then, 7 yrs ago).
Recently however i came across a point of view that somewhere rids me of a lot of that bookstore-guilt. Its called an Anti-Library, and Nassim Nicholas Taleb has put it across in his book - The Black Swan. It says that a read book is far less valuable than an unread one, for the books that decorate your shelf is a research tool. Now i may not be researching as much as much as i would be , some day, in a mood to read a certain kind of book...which still makes it associable. One will accumulate more knowledge and more books as they grow older. It would only mean i would be stacking up as many good books i think i should "have" and not necessarily "have read". With age i would have better idea of what is worth having. Concluding therefore that more you know, the more would be the collection of unread books. He therefore called this entire collection an Anti-Library. And he says, which i found the most interesting of lines i have read in recent times (and the reason for this blog) - that a library should contain as much of what you don't know as your financial means :-) ............ and i like that! And can live it for some time.
... The Black Swan was one of the eight books i bought/invested in my last guilt ridden (not anymore) trip to the book shop :)
it's an interesting concept - the anti library. but i don't see it working for me. i can't sleep easy with unread books on my shelf! and even with non-fiction *which, of course i don't read too often*, i can't put it down till i've read it cover to cover. i guess that's why i find non-fiction not too interesting. i feel rushed to read the whole book... and half of it doesn't give me anything new. hmm... hadn't thought of that before! :)
ReplyDeleteand abt the flora fountain - churchgate book buying... i can't buy pirated books! no matter how much money it'd save me... i couldn't ever get myself to buy them. also, some of them are dog-eared. i used to browse there... pick up dog-eared books and straighten them up and put them back! :D never bought one off there, though.
u knw it can fit in to ur scheme of thngs too! one cn always go bck to tht buks read already whn thr is greater relevance.
ReplyDeletedog ears are inevitable. but they wr nt pirated. jst passed on, fr it ws read already. they lukd old, tht yellow tinge to paper. you wud b pickn up an original but old, a part of tree already wasted, it havng gone thru a life beynd wht u wud gv it. it wud nt luk as great, but th releavance being the same.
why are dog ears inevitable? none of my books have them.
ReplyDeletei'll save trees some other way... it's like why i don't like to read library books. i want that book's ownership to start and end with me. :D
it doesn't make sense... but well...
i do re-read books. quite often, that too. and the relevance changes depending on my state-of-mind and the change in my perspective... sometimes, it signals to me abt how much i've changed.
my comments are really too long! :D
they are. wht cn i say, u like smthng, u earn in poor indian rupees, u wnt to read real bad, and if thts al tht mattrs, u buy. imagine a wife expecting her man to love her even whn she is fat:-D. Dogears are like fatwoman. i'd stl love em! dnt judge a buk by its cover, pleeease!
ReplyDelete:D
ReplyDeleteno no.. not judging by the cover... i would still read the same book. i used to wait till i could afford a bookstore copy, actually... :D
sorry abt the long comments! :P
Contrary to popular belief that wasn't a token guest appearance that I put in that time, I'm still here reading whatever you post. May I just request one tiny thing? Could you please not use short forms? (refer above comment) It's ummm... hard to read, like having to read and translate at the same time. I belong to the old school of grammatical and syntax guardians :P
ReplyDeleteI haven't been in Bombay for ages but I mourn the loss of the Flora Fountain booksellers... they provided me hours of browsing enjoyment every other weekend in another age :)
I don't know about the whole anti-library thing. I'm sitting on the fence with this one. I've got several books on my shelf which I haven't read and don't know when I'll bother reading... but I don't ever feel a sense of guilt for buying them and just keeping them. Books are meant to be treasured... and that's probably all there is to it. Bibliophiles collect books no matter what they think or feel about not reading them :)
'scuse zee long comment!
DD - The point is not agreement. its perspective. i maybe on your side in a few days:-).
ReplyDeleteR - A book is a book! let go.
you should judge a book beauty peagent.
I loudly declare myself an "anti-librarian". Thanks Anish... i can now walk with my head held high.
ReplyDeleteBTW- Black Swan would be part of the unread in my collection ;)
i completely agree on 'pride and guilt'. every time i look at my bookshelf, that's what exactly happens. i saw black swan lying on your table a few months back and i read the anti-library part and actually felt legitimised !!
ReplyDeleteyes unny - i think we all read for that moment of realisation, when you want to look up and think for sometime before reading again.
ReplyDelete